Teen to be tried as adult for fatal Middletown gang shooting


A 16-year-old Middletown teen will be tried as an adult following a hearing today in Butler County Juvenile Court. 

Gonnii White is charged with murder and participating in a criminal gang in the shooting death of Joesph Davis, 17, near the corner of Woodlawn Avenue and Garfield Street during the late night hours of May 29.

The teen showed no emotion during the hearing in Judge Kathleen Romans courtroom, even after the judge bound his case over to common pleas court for prosecution.

PREVIOUS REPORT: Teen suspect in Middletown fatal shooting has criminal past that includes gun charges

“I am sorry that it came to this son, but this is how we have to proceed,” Romans said to White. The teen had been on probation since 2016 through juvenile court for having a gun and threatening to shoot someone in a Middletown neighborhood.

White’s mother, who was asked to remove her sunglasses in the courtroom, sobbed when the judge announced the decision. A family member said, “We love you” as the teen left the courtroom in handcuffs and shackles.

Middletown Police Detective Kristi Hughes, who was at the fatal shooting scene, testified Davis was shot four times — in the neck, thigh, shoulder and buttocks. He was lying in a puddle of blood when she arrived on the scene and a bicycle and stuffed animal were nearby.

During questioning, Hughes said White admitted he shot Davis.

MORE: 911 caller describes finding 2 bodies behind vacant restaurant

“He (White) did state he was the one who shot Mr. Davis,” Hughes said. “He stated when he saw Mr. Davis, he thought he was reaching for a gun and began shooting.”

Hughes testified that she is trained in the investigation of gangs. She said she was able to determine White is a regional member member of a Crips gang called the Roadrunners.

White’s Facebook page and his cell phone contain images of him making gang signs, wearing blue (the Crips color) as well as Crips quotes and the Crips prayer, Hughes said.

Davis was a member of a rival gang, the Bloods, according to the detective.

Dawn Garrett, White’s attorney, pointed out while he was questioned by detectives he was lying across the table and appeared to be under the influence.

Hughes said she did not have a concern that White was under the influence, but he did have his head down on the table at times.

MORE: Teen killed in Reily Twp. after car collides with road equipment

Garrett also pointed out White was questioned by detectives without his parents present or notified. Romans said the teen’s mother was on vacation and his father “cannot be found.”

After binding the case over to adult court, Romans set bond for White at $750,000, noting the testimony that White may have been dealing drugs and may have been a member of a gang.

“I want to make sure this young man is available for trial,” Romans said.




Next Up in Local

7 treasures we found on a trip to Tipp City antique shop
7 treasures we found on a trip to Tipp City antique shop

When the holidays come around, local antique stores don’t often pick up on the decor component the way mainstream stores do. Midwest Memories Antiques in Tipp City takes the holidays very seriously. Never have we seen an antique store so fully embrace the spirit of Christmas. Nearly every vendor in the store had holiday merchandise and antiques...
Fully involved dwelling fire in Miami County under control
Fully involved dwelling fire in Miami County under control

A fully involved two-story dwelling fire occurred Sunday night in the 6200 block of Tipp-Elizabeth Road. The incident was reported around 8:30 p.m., according to dispatch. According to initial reports, all occupants were reportedly outside from the fire that was heavy on all floors. We are working to learn more and will update this page when more information...
First trailer for new ‘Downton Abbey’ movie released: ‘You’re cordially invited…’
First trailer for new ‘Downton Abbey’ movie released: ‘You’re cordially invited…’

“You are cordially invited to return to Downton Abbey.”  >> Read more trending news  The first official trailer for the eagerly anticipated movie based on the award-winning PBS Masterpiece drama was released with little detail about what might happen next at the Grantham estate, but it expressly invites fans to the big-screen...
Christmas gift fail? A toy that’s powered by yelling and chases kids is freaking people out
Christmas gift fail? A toy that’s powered by yelling and chases kids is freaking people out

“The louder you yell, the faster they go.” The advertising slogan for a new spider-like Hasbro toy line, Yellies, caters to the boisterous kid that gets a thrill out of voice-activated toys, but some critics are calling the toy a parent’s worst nightmare. >> Read more trending news  Hasbro introduced the controversial new...
Local photographers donate talent to help Montgomery County foster kids
Local photographers donate talent to help Montgomery County foster kids

Four local photographers came together Sunday to donate their time and use their talent to help foster kids. Montgomery County Children Services’ Foster Parent Advisory Committee (FPAC) came up with the idea to have the children professionally photographed. The organization says the pictures will then be put on the county’s adoption website...
More Stories