UPDATE:

Need a job? More than 160 employers will be at UD Arena

New Miami speed cameras case ripe for Supreme Court scrutiny


Attorneys for the speeders caught by New Miami speed cameras are asking the Ohio Supreme Court not to consider the village’s appeal in the $3 million-plus case.

The village filed with the high court in March after both Judge Michael Oster and the 12th District Court of Appeals denied its argument they can’t be sued because they are a government, performing the government function of traffic control.

Josh Engel, one of the speeders’ attorneys, filed a response with the court Tuesday saying this case has no great public interest value since it involves an old speed camera program that was discontinued and sovereign immunity protection for the village doesn’t apply.

RELATED: New Miami speed camera case travels to the Ohio Supreme Court

Generally speaking governments cannot by sued for performing their legal function, but the speeders contend that immunity only applies when someone sues say after being hit by a snow plow and the other driver wants money for pain and suffering. In this case the old speed camera program was found unconstitutional by now retired Judge Michael Sage, thus they contend New Miami must return the speeding fines it collected.

Engel wrote that just because the case involves money — an estimated $3.5 million with interest — doesn’t mean the statutes providing sovereign immunity govern this case.

“Ohio courts have been consistent in one significant and relevant respect in interpreting R.C. c. 2744: sovereign immunity has no application in actions for equitable relief…,” Engel wrote. “The class’s claim for equitable restitution based on unjust enrichment is one for equitable relief because the plaintiff class seeks to recover the specific funds that were wrongfully obtained by the village under the unconstitutional ordinance.”

The case has been rolling around the courts — this is the second time it has made its way to Columbus — since 2013, when a group of speeders, hit with the $95 traffic fine, sued the village. Earlier this year the 12th District sided with speeders that sovereign immunity isn’t available in this instance.

When he filed with the high court, the village’s outside counsel James Englert wrote this case does have great importance for municipalities who could go bankrupt over lawsuits and thus the court should accept jurisdiction.

“This case presents a critical issue of importance to municipalities across Ohio, in that the opinion of the Twelfth District below has deprived the village of New Miami of sovereign immunity guaranteed by the legislature in a statutory scheme this court has already recognized as necessary for the ‘preservation of the fiscal integrity of political subdivisions,” Englert wrote.

The high court only accepts jurisdiction in roughly seven percent — it was five percent in 2016 with 68 appeals accepted out of 1,381 filed — of the cases filed there annually.

Englert told the Journal-News this case is also critically important, and one the Supreme Court should take, because there is also the question of how much money is a violation of due process worth. Sage, and subsequently Butler County Common Pleas Judge Michael Oster who has the case now, found the speeders rights were trampled under the old ticketing and hearing process.

MORE: More appeals likely for New Miami speed camera case

“I think that’s what this case is all about, it’s all about how you measure the injury for due process,” Englert said, adding that question is ripe for Supreme Court scrutiny.

Engel in his reply also addressed this issue, saying New Miami has “artfully” reframed the issue at hand and even if this issue can be considered, immunity doesn’t apply.

“This is, significantly, an injury separate and distinct from compensation sought for the deprivation of property without due process,” Engel wrote. “Most important, even if the Village had correctly characterized the equitable restitution claim by the class (the village has not), the sovereign immunity statute still would not apply.”

To date, the lawsuit has cost taxpayers around $305,000 in legal fees. New Miami has to pay the legal bills out of pocket because this type of lawsuit isn’t covered under insurance.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

JUST IN: Pizza Hut to expand in Dayton area 
JUST IN: Pizza Hut to expand in Dayton area 

The Ohio-based franchisee for Pizza Hut has signed leases for two new Dayton-area restaurants after determining that the region is  under-served by the national pizza chain. “We are expanding in Dayton, and we are very excited,” Carol Magazzeni, director of marketing and public relations for Hallrich Inc., based in Stow in...
Trump project inspires new Hamilton boutique hotel
Trump project inspires new Hamilton boutique hotel

The historic Champion Paper administration building, located across North B Street from the Black Street Bridge, likely will become a boutique hotel as part of the gigantic Spooky Nook sports complex. “That’ll likely be a boutique hotel,” said Sam Beiler, who created the original Spooky Nook facility in Manheim, Pa. “We&rsquo...
Old Navy to open 60 new stores, remodel 150
Old Navy to open 60 new stores, remodel 150

The parent company of Old Navy is planning to open 60 more stores this year. Gap Inc., which operates the discount apparel brand, told CNBC it will also be remodeling about 150 Old Navy stores over the next few months. Most of those remodels will include upgrades to fitting rooms, bathrooms and check out areas and around 10 percent of those stores...
Looking to turn in unused prescription drugs? Here’s how
Looking to turn in unused prescription drugs? Here’s how

If you have unused or expired prescription drugs, this Saturday you can safely turn them in at dozens of area sites. National Prescription Drug Take-Back Day will be Saturday from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. Prescription drugs can be disposed at drop-off sites to reduce the risk of the prescriptions being abused. RELATED: Opioid prescribing sharply declines...
Bellbrook’s new city manager is also fitness instructor
Bellbrook’s new city manager is also fitness instructor

The new city manager in Bellbrook was a former administrator for the village of Yellow Springs, where she continues to lead fitness classes. Melissa Dodd started this month, taking over for Mark Schlagheck, the former city manager who accepted a position as the chief financial officer with The Jefferson Health Plan. STAY CONNECTED: Greene County News...
More Stories