‘Our world was turned upside down’: Man, 72, sentenced for crash that killed 74-year-old


A 72-year-old man was sentenced Tuesday to 45 days of house arrest, and his driver’s license was suspended for two years, for running a stop sign while on a delivery route and causing a crash that killed another man in his 70s.

Danny Hiler, of Georgetown, pleaded no contest and was convicted of vehicular manslaughter and a stop-sign violation during a hearing in Warren County Court.

The court provided Hiler headphones so that he could hear Judge Robert Fischer during sentencing in the criminal case stemming from the death of Fred Carmack Jr., 74, of Morrow.

RELATED: Troopers urge drivers to buckle up, pay attention after year’s 2nd fatal crash

The victim’s son said he, his sister and his father all lived within miles of each other.

“Our world was turned upside down that day,” Fred Carmack III said during the hearing.

“He was killed a half-mile from his house. It’s very surreal. I can’t accept to this day that it’s happened.”

The family and lawyers for the Fischer Auto Parts, owners of the car Hiler was driving and for which Hiler made deliveries, were still in negotiations, according to the son.

RELATED: Morrow man, 74, dies after crash in Warren County

“I have no memory of anything that day,” Hiler said, after saying he felt very badly about what happened.

According to the Ohio State Highway Patrol, Hiler was headed northeast on Ohio 132 in a 2018 Chevrolet Sonic when he ran the stop sign and crashed into the northwest-bound 2006 Chevrolet Impala driven by Carmack at 11:47 a.m. on Feb. 14.

The vehicles went off the side of the road, and Carmack’s struck a post for an Ohio 132 sign. He died en route to Bethesda Arrow Springs, according to the crash report.

Reports indicated neither driver was wearing a seat belt.

MORE: 18-year-old girl Warren County’s 13th fatal crash victim in 2018

No medical helicopter was available due to the weather conditions, according to the report.

Hiler also was badly injured and lost his job as a result of the crash, according to his lawyer, WM. Stewart Matthews II.

Fischer said he ordered maximum fines ($900) and would have considered jail time but felt the county jail was full of people charged with or serving time for intentionally committing crimes.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Are Bert and Ernie gay? 'Sesame Street' weighs in on ex-writer's comments
Are Bert and Ernie gay? 'Sesame Street' weighs in on ex-writer's comments

The nonprofit organization behind the beloved children's show "Sesame Street" is weighing in on a question that has sparked debates for decades: Are Bert and Ernie a gay couple? The answer: Nope, they're puppets, Sesame Workshop said in a statement Tuesday. "As we have always said, Bert and Ernie are best friends," the...
Bill Daniels gets to ‘make people happy all day’ as owner of Dayton’s Original Pizza Factory 
Bill Daniels gets to ‘make people happy all day’ as owner of Dayton’s Original Pizza Factory 

Bill Daniels is a self-professed cheerleader for the city of Dayton, and he has helped feed its people for more than three decades.  Daniels — co-founder and owner of Dayton's Original Pizza Factory, founding board member of Fifth Street Brewpub, and founder and former owner of South Park Tavern — is our Daytonian of the...
Morning showers possible, summer heat continues for afternoon 
Morning showers possible, summer heat continues for afternoon 

Few northern showers early this morning Heat index in the low 90s today and tomorrow Fall starts this weekend TODAY: A few passing showers are possible before sunrise in the far north. Sunshine and scattered clouds for the afternoon with highs in the upper 80s and a heat index nearing 90 degrees. There’s a chance for a pop up shower...
'Avengers 4' movie: Jeremy Renner teases bruised, bloody Hawkeye
'Avengers 4' movie: Jeremy Renner teases bruised, bloody Hawkeye

Actor Jeremy Renner wants you to know that Hawkeye will be returning to the upcoming untitled “Avengers 4” reshoot, despite the rumors. The superhero, along with Ant-Man and the Wasp, didn’t make it to Marvel’s Atlanta-filmed “Avengers: Infinity War,” but Renner is officially back in action for the next installation...
1 transported by CareFlight after Springfield motorcycle crash 
1 transported by CareFlight after Springfield motorcycle crash 

UPDATE @ 4 a.m.: One person was transported to a local hospital via CareFlight after a motorcycle crash occurred in Springfield early Wednesday. According to Springfield police, crews were called to the 1600 block of Miracle Mile when two riders were thrown from a single motorcycle after hitting a deer.  Initial reports indicate the driver...
More Stories