Probation or prison? 8 teacher sex crime cases show sentences vary widely


The latest teacher in this region to be convicted for having sex with a student is set be sentenced Tuesday.

The punishment awaiting former Miamisburg Middle School teacher Jessica Langford could range from probation to prison after a jury last month found her guilty of having sex in her classroom with a 14-year-old.

A recent investigation by this news organization into southwest Ohio teachers convicted of similar crimes showed a wide variation in punishments in such cases.

RELATED: Ex-teacher convicted of having sex with teen student touts ‘blemish-free’ record

Here are eight examples:

• 2010, Northeastern High School teacher: Anthony Parker was sentenced to 15 years in prison, but that sentence was later reduced. He pleaded guilty to four counts of sexual battery involving a girl, 16.

• 2011, Tecumseh Local Schools guidance counselor: Kristin Mastin was sentenced to five years’ probation. She pleaded guilty to three counts of sexual battery involving a 16-year-old.

RELATED: State seeks maximum sentence in ex-Miamisburg teacher’s sex crime conviction

• 2011, Mason High School teacher: Stacy Schuler was sentenced to four years in prison, served more than 1 year. Schuler was convicted in bench trial on 16 felony counts of sexual battery involving multiple high school students.

• 2013, Wayne High School teacher: Kelsey Hartmann was sentenced to five years’ probation. She pleaded guilty to unlawful sexual conduct with a minor after performing a sex act on a teen boy in her vehicle.

• 2013, Centerville High School teacher and girls golf coach: Michael Weaver was sentenced to five years’ probation. He pleaded guilty to having sex with a student during the 2005-06 school year.

RELATED: NEW DETAILS: Report says student claim teacher showed erotic photo, gave gifts

• 2015, New Miami teacher: Justin Madden was sentenced to 93 months in prison minus time served. He entered guilty pleas to four felony charges involving two girls, 16 and 18.

• 2017, Fairfield High School teacher: Tyler Conrad was sentenced to 180 days in jail minus time served. He was convicted in a bench trial of sexual imposition and contributing to the delinquency of a minor involving a girl, 16.

• 2018, Fairmont High School substitute teacher: Madelyn Marx was sentenced to five years’ probation. She pleaded guilty to two counts of sexual battery involving two males, 16 and 17.

MORE POPULAR ARTICLES ON THIS ISSUE:

RELATED: Sex cases with students swamp area schools

RELATED: Co-worker: Ex-Miamisburg teacher made odd requests in teen sex case

RELATED: Teen testifies he had sex with accused ex-Miamisburg teacher

RELATED: Guilty verdict: Things we’ve learned from the Miamisburg teacher trial

RELATED: Accused teacher seeks ‘escape routes’ in teen sex trial

RELATED: 9 concerns school had with teacher later convicted of teen sex crimes

RELATED: Job change loomed for ex-teacher accused of teen sex crimes

RELATED: Administrator: Teacher facing sex charges didn’t want to change buildings

RELATED: Records: School worried teacher flirted with students a year before sex charges



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Missing juvenile last seen in Franklin, has friends in Dayton area
Missing juvenile last seen in Franklin, has friends in Dayton area

A 16-year-old girl last seen in Franklin on Sunday is missing, according to Franklin police. Chelsea Lamb-Stephenson recently moved to Williams, Ind., but was visiting friends with her mother in Franklin when she went missing. She used to live in Mason and reportedly has friends in the areas of Dayton and Fairborn. Chelsea is 5’2”, 224...
Washington Twp. woman helping cancer patients with ‘Comfee Caps’
Washington Twp. woman helping cancer patients with ‘Comfee Caps’

When two of her closest friends were battling cancer eight years ago, Washington Township resident, Sue Forrest, decided to provide comfort to them in a very unique way. Little did she know that it turned into a much larger labor of love. MORE: Regional center now dispatching calls for Washington Twp. Forrest wanted to help her friends, who were undergoing...
Xenia High School employee on leave; sexual battery investigation underway
Xenia High School employee on leave; sexual battery investigation underway

A Xenia Community Schools employee is on paid administrative leave pending an investigation. The staff member, who works at the high school, was placed on leave Friday, said Wendy Planicka, spokeswoman for Xenia schools. A Xenia police report involving alleged sexual battery was obtained by this news organization following a public records request...
TODAY: Dayton school board may prohibit teachers, staff from ‘crowdfunding’
TODAY: Dayton school board may prohibit teachers, staff from ‘crowdfunding’

Dayton’s school board meets at 5 p.m. today with one unusual item on the agenda — a policy change prohibiting school employees from launching crowdfunding campaigns on behalf of Dayton Public Schools or any individual DPS school. Crowdfunding is described by Merriam-Webster as “the practice of obtaining needed funding (as for a new...
National Cheeseburger Day: We tried a new veggie option at Five Guys and were happily surprised 
National Cheeseburger Day: We tried a new veggie option at Five Guys and were happily surprised 

Today is National Cheeseburger Day and we understand that not everyone is going to want to participate in this meaty day of celebration.  There’s a non-beef, veggie option unveiled at Five Guys earlier this year that is a great alternative for anyone going out to dinner tonight with their patty-loving companions.  The Veggie Sandwich...
More Stories