Retired teachers non-profit faces allegations of theft, mismanagement


The recently fired executive director of a non-profit lodged a complaint with the Ohio Attorney General that alleges he was fired after uncovering corruption, fraud and theft.

John Cavanaugh, who was dismissed earlier this month by the Ohio Retired Teachers Association, said in his complaint: “This is an urgent matter as my office manager and I have been tipped off that the Executive Committee plans to destroy evidence of criminal activity and fraud once we are terminated.”

ORTA, a non-profit with roughly 20,000 members, keeps an eye on pension issues impacting retired Ohio teachers.

“Everything you got in front of you is just ridiculous,” said Randy Overbeck, president of the ORTA board, regarding Cavanaugh’s complaint. “John was fired for insubordination and breach of confidentiality.”

Cavanaugh declined to comment.

Related: Retired teachers to lose cost of living increase

Evelyn Massey, who joined ORTA as the office manager in April 2016, also filed a complaint with the Attorney General’s Charitable Law Section, detailing that she found a lack of documentation for credit card charges and extra paychecks issued to some ORTA employees.

But on Tuesday, Massey said she was pressured by Cavanaugh to file the complaint in February and now she wants to withdraw it. “He wanted me to go ahead and file a complaint, so I did. He was my boss,” she said.

She said she isn’t sure if the lack of documentation for some checks and charges is a matter of honest mistakes or something more serious.

In June 2016, Mark Anderson, a certified public accountant who reviewed ORTA financial records, told the board that the previous administration did not appear to know how to use the sophisticated accounting and bookkeeping software that ORTA purchased.

The accountant also flagged ORTA’s use of several credit cards, saying that charges were excessive, and he noted that ORTA’s investment performance has been below average.

In a February email to Overbeck, Cavanaugh outlined 21 steps he had taken as executive director to tighten internal controls, review investment performance, remedy tax errors with the IRS and monitor cash flow.

This newspaper obtained the Cavanaugh and Massey complaints from the Attorney General’s office through a public records request. The AG’s investigative records are not made public unless it results in a court case or settlement, a spokesman said.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Queen Elizabeth turns 92: 5 fun facts
Queen Elizabeth turns 92: 5 fun facts

Queen Elizabeth II turned 92 on Saturday, and after 65 years on the throne, she holds the distinction of ruling longer than any monarch in the United Kingdom’s history.  The queen actually celebrates two birthdays each year: her actual birthday, which is April 21; and one in June when she hosts a parade -- weather permitting -- called &ldquo...
Stormy Daniels' attorney talks about 'locked and loaded' DVD, Sean Hannity
Stormy Daniels' attorney talks about 'locked and loaded' DVD, Sean Hannity

The attorney for Stormy Daniels reiterated that a DVD of evidence of the adult film actress’ affair with President Donald Trump is “locked and loaded,” Newsweek reported.  Michael Avenatti appeared on HBO’s “Real Time With Bill Maher,” and in the online-only Overtime segment, the attorney was grilled...
OVI checkpoint leads to multiple arrests and citations, including for marijuana and guns
OVI checkpoint leads to multiple arrests and citations, including for marijuana and guns

Several people were arrested Friday night during an OVI checkpoint in Fairfield. Pete Reising, Butler County OVI Task Force coordinator, said of the 304 vehicles checked between 11 p.m. and 1:40 a.m. at the checkpoint on Ohio 4 just north of Symmes Road, 11 vehicles were diverted for further investigation by Fairfield police, Butler County Sheriff&rsquo...
Find out where Centerville will spend more than $4M to fix streets
Find out where Centerville will spend more than $4M to fix streets

Centerville will move ahead with plans to improve its infrastructure, using funding from its annual street program budget to repair more than 20 of the possible 256 total lane miles in the community. After an income tax levy passed in 2016, the city council added money to the annual street program budget, Maureen Russell Hodgson of the community resources...
Woman impaled during crash: 'I don't know how I'm alive'
Woman impaled during crash: 'I don't know how I'm alive'

A Massachusetts woman said she was happy to be alive after being impaled by a pole in an automobile accident. Katherine Ibanez, 31, was driving in Attleboro on April 3 when she said she swerved to avoid another car. "My car just spun all the way around. And then when I looked down, I had a pole stuck right here,” Ibanez said, pointing to...
More Stories