School expert: How to help at-risk students and know where ‘the line’ is


Schools aiming to minimize violent incidents should teach students and staff how to reach out to at-risk students, as well identify which types of warning signs are most serious, an Ohio school psychologist says.

Local schools have fortified doors, added cameras and in some cases armed staff in recent years, but Erich Merkle, past president of the Ohio School Psychologists Association, said interpersonal work is critically important to school safety.

At-risk students

Merkle encouraged students and school staff to reach out to three groups of students specifically – those who are marginalized, bullied or disconnected from the school society; those who are having academic and significant behavioral problems; and those who have gone through some painful, life-changing event.

RELATED: Schools focus on behavior management plans

“There is a fairly consistent set of features from these active shooter situations,” Merkle said. “These are kids that typically are marginalized. They may be bullied or tormented. They are outliers, not part of major social groups.”

He cautioned that plenty of students fit those profiles without having outbursts. But he encouraged schools to try to bring those students into the larger social group of the school and help them build connections rather than letting them be mocked or ostracized.

Merkle said obvious signs – clear threats in person or on social media, or a spate of behavioral incidents – should be dealt with immediately. He pointed to Akron schools’ threat assessment matrix, which includes flow charts for clear steps to take depending on the severity of the issue.

RELATED: Threats rock local schools; four arrests made

And he encouraged schools not to get lost solely in the discipline side of such cases, instead making sure that counseling or mental health angles are explored so the root causes can be addressed.

“Students finally reach a point where they’re not able to deal with it, and they emotionally react,” Merkle said.

He added that while there is value to school safety drills, school psychologists worry about the impact that intense active-shooter drills can have on young students. He urged schools to give kids a chance to talk about and process those events after they happen.

To report or not report

Many schools repeat the safety mantra, “If you see something, say something.” But one of the hardest things for students to do is decide whether they should report a certain behavior or comment to school officials – especially when it came from a friend or teammate.

Merkle said schools have to establish that it’s OK to let somebody know what’s going on if you’re concerned about a person’s welfare. He said schools that use the Positive Behavior Interventions and Supports system (PBIS) try to build that culture on a regular basis, not just when there’s an incident.

RELATED: Frustrated students plan walkout protests

But there’s still that question – where’s the line? Merkle said that decision involves determining the seriousness and specificity of the comment, and the ability and resources of a person to carry it out. He advised starting a threat assessment anytime there is a threat of “death, disfigurement or intractable pain, suffering or harm.”

“You do hear all the time – I’m gonna kill him, or I could just kill him,” Merkle said. “That does imply death, but the next question is, does this person have the capacity and resources to pull it off. If a kindergartener says I’m going to blow up Ms. Jones’ house, more than likely, they don’t have the capacity or resources to do it. But when a high schooler says, I’m going to jump Ms. Jones, key up her car and choke her, now there is an impending sense that this actually could occur.”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Join Rev. Jasper Williams Jr. at Dayton church service tonight
Join Rev. Jasper Williams Jr. at Dayton church service tonight

The Eulogist at Aretha Franklin’s funeral will be attending the 5:30 p.m. service Sunday night at a Dayton church. The Rev. Jasper Williams Jr. will be the guest speaker at St. Luke Missionary Baptist Church, 2262 N. Gettysburg Ave., for Men’s Day, according to a release.  The service will also feature a men’s chorus led by Rev...
West Carrollton wants land near I-75 for proposed entertainment district
West Carrollton wants land near I-75 for proposed entertainment district

West Carrollton plans to buy more land near Interstate 75 and the Great Miami River for nearly $500,000, expanding its control and development options for an approved entertainment district. The city is looking to buy two small pieces of riverfront property, giving it about five contiguous acres near I-75’s Exit 47 on the Great Miami River. It...
$1.1M roundabout planned at Xenia intersection
$1.1M roundabout planned at Xenia intersection

Roundabouts are becoming a popular alternative to traffic lights at intersections, and plans are underway to install one at a wide four-way stop in a neighborhood northeast of downtown Xenia. The city of Xenia and the Ohio Department of Transportation are working on the final details of the plan for a roundabout to be installed at North Columbus (U...
Police investigating body found in roadway as homicide
Police investigating body found in roadway as homicide

Middletown police are investigating the death of a man found in the roadway early this morning as a homicide, according to Lt. Scott Reeve. The man was found dead about 12:30 a.m. in a residential community at Lefferson Road and Sheffield Street. There are no arrests, according to Reeve, who declined to release more details. Identification will be...
OSP: Man trapped inside truck for several hours, taken to Springfield Regional
OSP: Man trapped inside truck for several hours, taken to Springfield Regional

UPDATE @ 9:55 a.m.: A man was transported to Springfield Regional Medical Center this morning for unknown injuries after flipping over a bridge in a pick-up truck off W. County Line Rd.  According to the Ohio State Highway Patrol, the man was traveling westbound on W. County Line Rd., veered to the left, then flipped over the bridge around...
More Stories