Should servers give their bosses more control over their tips?


A proposed Department of Labor rule altering how employee tips are controlled and distributed may sound obscure, but the idea has received more than 200,000 public comments and is getting national attention.

The proposed U.S. Labor Department rule change how much control employers have over tips. Under the change, employers could keep tips as long as all their workers are paid at least federal minimum wage — $7.25 an hour.

That would be a change from a rule set up in 2011 that let restaurant owners require tipped employees to participate in tip pools only if the pool is shared among other traditionally tipped workers—such as servers, bussers and bartenders. Those employees are considered customer-facing, “front of house” staff.

MORESenators protest tips rule, say it would allow “stealing”

Proponents say sharing the tips with “back of the house” staff — like cooks and dishwashers — would address a disparity in pay between tipped and non-tipped employees.

“We think it’s unfair for a busboy who picks up dirty dishes to be able to get tips but for a dishwasher who cleans the dishes not to be allowed to share the tips,” Angelo Amador, an executive with the National Restaurant Association, told the New York Times recently.

But critics protest that nothing in the rule would actually require employers to distribute the tips, as long as all workers are paid at least minimum wage.

Brandi Ehrhart, a server at the Golden Jersey Inn located at Young’s Jersey Dairy is wary of the proposed rule.

Tips aren’t just icing or something extra for someone like Ehrhart. It’s a mainstay in how she makes her living. Weekends and busier days can lead to more lavish tips — so the harder a tipped employee works, the more she or he can earn.

“I’ve been doing this for close to 16 years,” Ehrhart said. “So it’s definitely my salary.”

RELATEDCleveland Fed president reassures Dayton audience on stock concerns

At the Golden Jersey Inn, waiters and waitresses don’t simply serve. They bus and clean their own tables, Ehrhart said.

At Young’s, tipped employees keep their tips. But Ehrhart said she has had to work at other places where tips were required to be shared.

“The only part that I don’t like about sharing is, you know, if somebody is not doing their job,” she said. “I am more than OK to share if they’re helping me and doing something. But if not, it doesn’t seem fair.”

MORE: DP&L has given hints of financial stresses



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

WPAFB Thursday Weather: Sunshine, low humidity continue 
WPAFB Thursday Weather: Sunshine, low humidity continue 

WRIGHT PATTERSON AIR FORCE BASE—Humidity levels remain low for the day as plenty of sunshine is expected. Temperatures reach back into the lower 80s. Friday’s forecast continues the calm weather and warm temperatures in the mid-80s. Heat and humidity begin to build for the weekend with the chance for pop-up thunderstorms Saturday and Sunday...
Gravesites overrun for Civil War veterans at Miami County cemetery
Gravesites overrun for Civil War veterans at Miami County cemetery

Jackson Cemetery just outside Piqua is home to Civil War veterans and many African-Americans who were born slaves but died free. The cemetery has been a historical landmark for the last 10 years. However, of concern to Piqua resident Della Shaffer is that some of these historical gravesites are overrun by brush. She knows of nine veterans buried here...
Collision involving private ambulance, passenger car snarls traffic
Collision involving private ambulance, passenger car snarls traffic

A collision involving a private ambulance and a passenger car on Linden Avenue at East Third Street ended with no injuries, police said.  The accident was dispatched about 8:15 p.m.  The MedPro ambulance was empty and was not on a call, according to police. The other car, a small Saturn, had a small child inside.  Police tell us they're...
Tick outbreaks appear to be on the rise, Dayton veterinarian says
Tick outbreaks appear to be on the rise, Dayton veterinarian says

There are common misconceptions among many people when it comes to ticks, says one Dayton veterinarian who has seen a recent rise in outbreaks.  Dr. Daniel Brauer with Dayton South Veterinary Clinic says ticks can latch on to people and pets anywhere outside, not just on trails and tall grass. Relying on spurts of colder weather also won&rsquo...
2 injured in collision involving semi on U.S. 127 in Darke County, near Ansonia
2 injured in collision involving semi on U.S. 127 in Darke County, near Ansonia

UPDATE @ 10:15 p.m.: U.S. 127 North and South will remain closed as deputies investigate the collision involving a semitrailer and a passenger that sent two people in the car to a hospital.  Both victims were in the car, which appears to have failed to yield and pulled into the path of the semitrailer at the intersection of Reed Road and state...
More Stories