breaking news

Roost to close Kettering location this fall

Lawmakers look to make it harder for issues to be put on the ballot


A Miami Valley lawmaker wants to make it more difficult to put issues and constitutional amendments before Ohio voters.

State Rep. Niraj Antani, R-Miamisburg, introduced a joint resolution that would increase the number of signatures needed to get an item on the ballot and increase the vote total needed to pass a measure from a majority to 60 percent.

The goal, Antani said, is to keep out-of-state interests out of Ohio politics.

“It is time for Ohioans to take our initiative process back and stop well-funded, out-of-state special interests from coming into our state and wreaking havoc,” Antani said in announcing the resolution.

RELATED: What is Ohio Issue 2?

The joint resolution would amend Ohio’s constitution and would have to go before voters to be approved if passed by the legislature.

The measure would also ban campaigns from paying the people who collect signatures for ballot issue petitions.

“It should be difficult,” Antani said of the process to get something on the ballot. “You’re amending the constitution.”

The proposed rules would apply to both citizen initiated constitutional amendments and initiated statutes.

Antani cited the recreational marijuana issue in 2015 and the current Issue 2 on prescription drug prices as instances when out-of-state groups funded measures on Ohio’s ballot.

Support for Issue 2 has been almost entirely funded by the AIDS Healthcare Foundation, a California-based non-profit that serves 800,000 HIV and AIDS patients around the globe, including in Ohio.

The non-profit spent more than $1.8 million on a consulting company to hire petition signature gatherers. The price-per-signature to get Issue 2 on the ballot was $10.13.

Antani said he had to go back 13 years, to the Ohio Definition of Marriage amendment in 2004 to find a ballot issue that was initiated at a grassroots level in Ohio.

Financial support for that ballot issue came mainly from Citizens for Community Values, which is an Ohio organization, but is an arm of the national Family Research Council, which pushed same-sex marriage bans across the country in the early 2000s.

“Time and time again for the last 13 years it has been special interests and out-of-state interests,” Antani said.

RELATED: Ohio’s drug price ballot issue: What’s really going on?

Ohio’s process to get measures on the ballot and ultimately change the state constitution is fairly minimal compared to some other states and to the federal process, according to Mark Caleb Smith, director of the Center for Political Studies at Cedarville University.

“Making it harder to amend the constitution isn’t necessarily a bad thing,” he said.

Every change that makes it harder for out-of-state interests to get on the ballot, however, will also make it harder for Ohio residents to initiate a ballot issue.

“It’s interesting to be pushing this direction when it looks like politics across the country is becoming more populous,” Smith said. “I’m not sure how it will fit politically.”

Other states require a supermajority to pass constitutional amendments, but no others have that high of a threshold for passing state statutes, according to Ballotpedia, a non-partisan elections resource.

Florida and Illinois require a 60 percent supermajority to pass a constitutional amendment. Colorado just increased the threshold to 55 percent.

RELATED: Issue 2 is most expensive ballot issue in Ohio history

No other state bans payment to those who collect signatures, according to Ballotpedia, but some ban paying them per signature. Ohio had such a ban, but it was struck down by a federal court in 2006 as unconstitutional.

Of 76 citizen-initiated measures on statewide ballots in 2016, only seven were achieved using volunteers to gather signatures. Those occurred in North Dakota and South Dakota where about 13,000 signatures were required per ballot measure compared to Ohio’s more than 180,000 for Issue 2 and more than 300,000 for Issue 1 this year.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Politics

U.S. doesn’t know where as many as 1,500 immigrant children are, Ohio Sen. Portman says
U.S. doesn’t know where as many as 1,500 immigrant children are, Ohio Sen. Portman says

Sen. Rob Portman expressed astonishment at Trump administration officials Thursday who seemed unable to say for certain the whereabouts of as many as 1,500 immigrant children who entered the United States on their own during the past few years. At a Senate subcommittee hearing, Portman, R-Ohio, seemed frustrated that “no one’s responsible&rdquo...
Omarosa talks about time at Central State, working with DDN in new book
Omarosa talks about time at Central State, working with DDN in new book

Omarosa Manigault Newman — the love-to-hate villain on “The Apprentice” who took a job in President Trump’s administration before writing her post-firing tell-all book — got her first taste of politics and the media as a student at Central State University. Manigault Newman’s student career at the historically Black...
Governor candidates DeWine, Cordray lay out economic plans for Dayton business leaders
Governor candidates DeWine, Cordray lay out economic plans for Dayton business leaders

The two men running to be governor — Democrat Richard Cordray and Republican Mike DeWine — each made the case Thursday that Ohio needs to address the workforce development gap with a full-spectrum of training programs. “This is really a tragedy that we have in the state of Ohio that we have many people who want to work but they don&rsquo...
Report: America hasn’t done enough to protect immigrant children from trafficking
Report: America hasn’t done enough to protect immigrant children from trafficking

A Senate panel chaired by Sen. Rob Portman concludes that the federal government has failed to take responsibility for making certain that immigrant children who enter the United States on their own are kept safe or making certain they show up for immigration hearings. In a scathing report which criticizes both the Obama and Trump administrations,...
UD grad and Republican congressman David Joyce takes on Trump in TV ad
UD grad and Republican congressman David Joyce takes on Trump in TV ad

University of Dayton graduate David Joyce, who faces re-election in his northeast Ohio congressional district this fall, boasts in a TV commercial that he stood up to President Donald Trump to protect Lake Erie. It marks one of the first commercials across the country in which a GOP lawmaker breaks with Trump. In a 30-second advertisement that aired...
More Stories