breaking news

Sears files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection

What is impact of Supreme Court ruling in Ohio voter purge case?

The Supreme Court ruled Monday that Ohio’s law for removing voters from registration rolls does not violate federal law.

The vote was split 5-4 with the conservative justices in the majority. Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr., said the court rejected arguments in the Ohio case that the practice violates a federal law intended to increase the ranks of registered voters.

RELATED: Supreme Court upholds Ohio voter purge law

The dissent, written by Justice Sonia Sotomayor says the law disenfranchises poor and minority voters.

Here’s a look at five takeaways from the court ruling:

1. You may have to re-register if you don’t vote regularly

Under the Ohio law, the state may kick people off the rolls if they skip a few elections and fail to respond to a notice from election officials. After skipping one federal election (every two years) voters get a notice. If they don’t respond and don’t vote in the next four years, they are removed from the voter rolls. Basically, voters are removed from the rolls if they miss three federal elections over six years and fail to return an address-confirmation card.

2. Impact on local election workers

One hurdle is likely to come from local governments, where election administrators would have to deal with disgruntled voters and manage an increase in the number of people placed on inactive voter lists, said Myrna Perez, who has studied voter list practices in her role as deputy director of the Brennan Center’s Democracy Program.

“Using one election as an indicator is going to lead to a whole lot of false positives,” she said. “There are plenty of states that clean their voter rolls successfully without being as aggressive as Ohio.”

3. Ohio has been purging voters for a while

Ohio has used voters’ inactivity to trigger the removal process since 1994. Yet groups representing voters did not sue over the policy until 2016, after Republican Secretary of State Jon Husted tightened the approach of his predecessor, Democrat Jennifer Brunner.

Brunner’s policy was to wait for two missed federal elections — not just one — before sending the address notification to voters.

4. Do other states do this?

Yes, but none of them have a schedule that moves as fast as Ohio’s. In most states with similar laws, the voter purge process begins after voters miss two or more federal elections. In Ohio, the process starts after missing one. Oklahoma, Georgia, Montana, Oregon, Pennsylvania and West Virginia have laws similar to Ohio’s.

RELATED Husted says replacing voting machines will be costly

5. Both sides make their case

Republicans have pushed for such restrictions, arguing without evidence that they are needed to combat what they say is widespread voter fraud. Democrats have pushed back, countering that the efforts are part of an attempt to suppress voting by Democratic constituencies, particularly minorities.

The New York Times and the AP contributed to this report.

RELATED Supreme Court to hear arguments over Ohio voter purge law

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Politics

Group of regional mayors and city managers comes out against Issue 1
Group of regional mayors and city managers comes out against Issue 1

A group of Dayton area officials has joined opponents of Issue 1 on November election ballots. This week, the Greater Dayton Mayors Ohio Municipal and Managers Association announced opposition to the proposed constitutional amendment. The regional organization, including elected and staff leaders from Beavercreek, Oakwood, Troy and Kettering among...
Brown has raised $27M in Senate race
Brown has raised $27M in Senate race

Sen. Sherrod Brown has raised nearly $27.1 million so far in his quest to receive a third term in the U.S. Senate — a figure higher even than Sen. Rob Portman’s total fund-raising in 2016. Brown, an Ohio Democrat, had almost $8.2 million on hand for his contest against Republican Rep. Jim Renacci, a Wadsworth Republican. Between July 1...
Multiple Warren County officials announce their opposition to Issue 1
Multiple Warren County officials announce their opposition to Issue 1

Warren County elected officials declared their opposition to Issue 1, citing what they believe would be the negative effects from their various positions. Issue 1 is a proposed constitutional amendment on November election ballots that would change sentencing guidelines for some drug crimes and affect other aspects of those crimes. Recorder Linda Oda...
When, where to expect traffic delays Friday during President Trump’s visit to Lebanon
When, where to expect traffic delays Friday during President Trump’s visit to Lebanon

UPDATE @ 12:38 p.m.: The city of Lebanon has released more information about traffic delays and road closures ahead of President’s Trump visit Friday. Temporary road closures lasting about 45 minutes for all major north to south routes in Lebanon will take place before and after the president’s rally at the Warren County Fairgrounds...
Sheriff offers advice for President Trump’s Warren County rally
Sheriff offers advice for President Trump’s Warren County rally

The Warren County Sheriff’s Office today explained some of the rules for the public concerning President Donald Trump’s rally Friday evening at the Warren County Fairgrounds in Lebanon. “For those planning to attend, please know the Fairgrounds will not be open to the public before 2 p.m. on Friday. If you arrive early, you will be...
More Stories