‘This one belongs to the Reds,’ Ohio Supreme Court says in tax case


The Cincinnati Reds chalked up a win Wednesday in a fight over whether the franchise should pay sales taxes on bobbleheads and other promotional items given to fans who attend home games.

The Ohio Supreme Court ruled 5-2 that the team didn’t have to pay taxes on the trinkets since the Reds demonstrated that the cost of the items were factored into the ticket prices.

“This one belongs to the Reds,” the majority opinion said, quoting the longtime Reds announcer Marty Brennaman.

Related: Supreme Court to consider Reds bobblehead case

The case stems from an Ohio tax commissioner audit of the Reds that included team purchases from 2008 to 2010. The commissioner ruled that the team had to pay use taxes on the items, such as bobbleheads, bats, shirts and other merchandise.

The Reds appealed that ruling to the Ohio Board of Tax Appeals and then to the Ohio Supreme Court.

Writing for the majority opinion, Justice Patrick Fischer cautioned that the ruling may not apply to other pro sports teams that sponsor promotional giveaways.

In the 22-page opinion, Fischer provides a short history of baseball in Ohio and its intersection with business and the courts. He also details the transformation of pro baseball into more than just a game and how teams have gone to great lengths to entertain fans with fireworks, expanded dining options, concerts and bobbleheads.



Reader Comments


Next Up in Local

Going to concerts, games and events in Columbus is about to get more expensive 
Going to concerts, games and events in Columbus is about to get more expensive 

It is going to soon be more expensive to attend many events, games and concerts in Columbus. >> MUST-TRY: These beefy burgers are well worth the drive east on I-70 Columbus City Council enacted a 5 percent admission tax on most arts and cultural events in the city, Monday night, according to the Columbus Dispatch and other...
Off-duty Dayton cop attended police ball before burglary arrest where he appeared drunk, telling officers: ‘I’m going to throw up in the back seat of your car.’ 
Off-duty Dayton cop attended police ball before burglary arrest where he appeared drunk, telling officers: ‘I’m going to throw up in the back seat of your car.’ 

Hours before his arrest on suspicion of burglary after allegedly kicking in a door of a residence in the early morning hours of Nov. 11, off-duty Dayton Police Officer Torrence E. LaPrath attended a police ball held at the Dayton FOP hall, a Dayton Daily News investigation found. Dayton FOP President Rick Oakley confirmed that LaPrath attended the...
Area stores to stay open 83 nonstop hours leading up to Christmas
Area stores to stay open 83 nonstop hours leading up to Christmas

Kohl’s won’t close its doors for 83 straight hours leading up to Christmas, giving even the night owls a chance to shop at the stores. Once Kohl’s stores open at 7 a.m. Dec. 21, it won’t close again until 6 p.m. Christmas Eve, an annual shopping marathon. »BIZ BEAT: Online holiday shopping expected to logjam delivery:...
Report: Christmas presents stolen from Dayton garage
Report: Christmas presents stolen from Dayton garage

A Grinch broke into a Dayton woman’s garage and stole multiple Christmas presents, according to a police report. The woman told police that she noticed the Delphos Avenue home’s garage was partially open around 9:30 a.m. Monday. When she checked the garage, she saw that Christmas presents she was keeping in there were missing. The...
12 Days of Cheese starts at area grocery store: You won’t believe the 11th day
12 Days of Cheese starts at area grocery store: You won’t believe the 11th day

Whole Foods Market on Wednesday will kick off its 12 Days of Cheese. Every day starting Wednesday, the retailer will have a new cheese priced 50 percent off. Amazon Prime members will also get another 10 percent off the sale price. “From funky to mild, creamy to crumbly, these cheeses aren’t just any cheeses; we searched the world to find...
More Stories