12 Dayton burgers that give you the best bang for your buck

Today, Sept. 18, is National Cheeseburger Day 🍔, so I suggest you block out some time to grab a thick, juicy burger to celebrate.

>> Your ultimate guide to the best burgers in Dayton

If you are in the market for fresh destinations to secure a solid case of the meat sweats in beef patty form, you could always go with the burger restaurant brand of the year announced by the Harris Poll EquiTrend Study earlier this year — Five Guys Burgers and Fries, which was No. 1 for the year after some fairly exhaustive polling across the country.

Or, you could opt to go with something off the beaten path.

Here is my short list of throwback diners and gritty dives that offer the best bang for your burger buck with a healthy dose of history served up alongside beef patties that are flavorful and done right.

This list represents some destinations worth visiting if nothing else for the fun adventure they provide. Not all burgers are created equal, but sometimes the location and atmosphere helps add another layer of deliciousness to the meal.

🍔 Benjamin’s The Burger Master

100 N. Main St., Dayton

937-223-8702 | Website

When you have “Burger Master” in your name and the subject is hamburgers, it’s the equivalent of throwing down the gauntlet. This underrated Dayton restaurant does a lot more than burgers and the cafeteria style set-up is an entertaining throwback. The burgers are as tasty as the prices.

>> The burger joint to have on your Bucket List

🍔 Blind Bob’s

430 E. Fifth St., Dayton

937-938-6405 | Website 

The stuffed burgers at Blind Bob’s are some of my favorites in town. The Island Delight Burger ($10) stuffed with sweet pineapple and zippy pepper-jack cheese, covered in a teriyaki glaze with a tangy wasabi-mayonnaise is a favorite, but any of the many stuffed burger options will impress and satisfy.

>> Blind Bob’s also a great destination for live, local music

🍔 George’s Family Restaurant

5216 N. Dixie Drive, Dayton

937-275-0705 | Website

George’s was voted Dayton’s Best Diner in the Dayton.com Best of Dayton poll. It won with voters for a reason — it’s a great spot to grab grub with a extensive menu at reasonable prices. There are nine burgers to choose from ranging in price from $4.75 to $7.95.

>> Winners of the 2016 Best of Dayton contest

🍔 Hasty Tasty Pancake House

3509 Linden Ave., Dayton


This old-school establishment is a great place to grab breakfast. It also has a “Tasty” burger that’s has all of the makings of a Frisch’s Big Boy sandwich, but on a more robust scale. For my money you can’t go wrong with tartar sauce on a burger and this burger delivers it in spades.

>> 6 must-try Dayton-area diners

🍔 K’s Hamburger Shop

117 E. Main St., Troy

937-339-3902 | Website 

This throwback diner grinds its own beef into some of the most affordable hamburgers you can get in the region. The five homemade soups (vegetable, potato, beef, noodle and chili) and homemade salads offer great pairing opportunities. If you yearn for a healthy dose of Americana, look no further.

🍔 Kewpee Hamburgers

111 N. Elizabeth, Lima


This is a drive to consider when the leaves start painting a gorgeous fall canopy. The second-oldest hamburger chain in the U.S. after White Castle has very few locations left, but three are in Lima, Ohio. Their slogan is “Hamburger pickle on top, makes your heart go flippity-flop!” Get ready for a great big dose of nostalgia and some semi-creepy baby dolls.

>> 9 must-eat sandwiches in Dayton

🍔 Maid-Rite Sandwich Shoppe

125 N. Broadway St., Greenville

937-548-9340 | Website 

This Darke County institution’s sandwiches that it is known for are less burger, more steamed loose-meat, but it’s got all of the same ingredients, just easier to chew. This little brick building with a wall of old gum wrapping it up has been in business since 1934 with a recipe and vision that remains the same. Grab a shake or a malt and you’ll be in business.

>> The story behind the famous little sandwiches people will drive miles to get

🍔 Nick’s Restaurant

1443 N. Detroit St., Xenia

937-372-3202 | Website 

Located off of the bike path along U.S. 68 in Xenia, the restaurants Big Nick half-pound burgers are a staple — add bacon and cheese and Nick’s special sauce for a total of $8.49. There are other burger options featured on the menu, but this is definitely the one to start with.

>> Nick’s is also famous for its chicken wings!!

🍔 Old Hickory Bar-B-Q

241 Woodman Drive, Dayton

(937) 253-4065 | Website

With nine hamburger options ranging in price from $4.25 to $5.25, this is a destination that’s easy on the wallet. Most of the burgers come dressed with BBQ sauce, so get ready for a little zing-zing.

>> Best places to grab barbecue in Dayton

🍔 Slyder’s Tavern

836 Watervliet Ave., Dayton

937-258-1222 | Website 

If you haven’t been to Slyder’s, make a plan to get there. Winner of the 2016 Best of Dayton poll, this is a burger that has continued to impress me for years. A seven-ounce cheeseburger is a modest $6.45, while a 10-ounce will set you back $7.15. This is a modest little neighborhood bar that puts out really great food and has been one of my go-to spots for years.

>> Secrets behind Slyder’s sinfully juicy burgers

🍔 Tank’s Bar & Grill

2033 Wayne Ave., Dayton

937-252-2249 | Website

Known for its half-pound Tankburger ($7.49), this is a creation that demands you arrive hungry. Add some cheese and grilled mushroom and onion, and you are seriously cooking.

>> What’s on the menu at Tank’s?

🍔 Voltzy’s Rootbeer Stand

4668 Springboro Pike, Moraine


There is nothing, and I mean nothing, flashy about Voltzy’s, which is part of its great charm. That and the flavorful personality of owner Rick Volz only adds to the experience. This menu is probably the one on this list that has the most fun with the modest cheeseburger. The “Betty Ann” is a steal at just $3.40 for a double cheeseburger with raw onion, pickle, mayo and double cheese. I also love the “Yuna Lee” — a double cheeseburger with an onion ring, sweet mustard and horsey sauce. If you are looking to entertain on a budget, 10 sliders will set you back just $12. Any on this list are delicious options that are priced right, but I’ll likely be scheduling a trip to see Rick tomorrow. Voltzy’s burgers are what National Cheeseburger Day is all about!

>> Voltzy’s has a Trump Burger, and here’s what’s on it

Reader Comments

Next Up in Food & Dining

‘Christmas Eve baby’ getting his due 100 years later
‘Christmas Eve baby’ getting his due 100 years later

Everett Walker knows what it is like to be short-changed for his birthday.  He’s essentially had 99 years worth of experience. Come Dec. 24,  you can make that 100 years.  Born on Christmas Eve 1918, Walker turns the big 1-0-0  on Monday, Dec. 24. Just like many people born around the holidays, Walker typically got the...
3 Dayton dining treasures to discover in charming Tipp City
3 Dayton dining treasures to discover in charming Tipp City

During the holiday season, a visit to Tipp City should involve two missions — shopping and dining. Neither will disappoint. Downtown dining highlights in walking distance from shopping include Harrison’s, Coldwater Cafe, Sam and Ethel’s and the Grounds for Pleasure Coffeehouse. Uptown and a short car ride away, dinner can be enjoyed...
Mexican street food, ‘crazy flavors’ and nearly everything else served at new Huber Heights restaurant 
Mexican street food, ‘crazy flavors’ and nearly everything else served at new Huber Heights restaurant 

One of the Dayton area’s newest restaurants offers flavors for your taste buds and your eyeballs.  Bright and boldly decorated in a rainbow of colors, Pepe’s Mexican Flavors has a menu packed with everything from Doriliocos (a bag of Doritos served with pickled skin pork, cucumber, jicama, pico de gallo, lemon, peanuts and...
Cold? This new restaurant serves up big ole bowls of hot, delicious soup 
Cold? This new restaurant serves up big ole bowls of hot, delicious soup 

Few things are as satisfying on a cold day than a big ole bowl of hot, delicious soup.  The Vistro Modern Vietnamese , one of Dayton’s newest restaurants, has big ole bowls of soup in abundance at its brick and mortar  location, 3937 Linden Ave., launched in July.  The Vistro is the latest ethnic restaurant to make the space...
5 great places to throw your next party
5 great places to throw your next party

If we’re being honest with ourselves, we have to admit that the annual holiday work party is about the only time of year some of us can stand being around some of our co-workers. That doesn’t make us bad people. It just makes the importance of a night with co-workers — away from the workplace, and with good spirits — that much...
More Stories