Ask Hal: Mesoraco will be relegated to reserve, pinch-hit duty

Hall of Fame baseball writer Hal McCoy knows a thing or two about our nation’s pastime. Tap into that knowledge by sending an email to

Q: If Billy Hamilton wants to win a Gold Glove, should he revert back to playing shortstop? DAVE, Miamisburg/Centerville/Beavercreek.

A: The last time Billy Hamilton was seen at shortstop, he made 39 errors in 133 games for the 2011 Dayton Dragons. They were mostly throwing errors and the Dragons issued catcher’s masks to fans sitting behind first base. The fact that Hamilton hasn’t won a Gold Glove is one of baseball’s many great mysteries. Amazingly, his arm is as accurate as a professional archer in center field and he covers 10 times the real estate there than he could at shortstop. His problem is that he can’t seem to cover that little rectangle where he stands with a bat in his hands.

Q: What are the plans for Devin Mesoraco if he is healthy enough to be somewhere on the field? — KEITH, Brookville.

A: At best, he will be Tucker Barnhart’s backup and play a couple of games a week, plus pinch-hitting late in games. If the Reds keep two catchers, manager Bryan Price can’t use Mesoraco to pinch-hit before the eighth or ninth innings because there won’t be a third catcher. The Reds probably would like to trade Mesoraco, but he has played only 95 games the past three years and will make $13.1 million on the last year of a four-year contract. That makes him nearly impossible to trade. And as a catcher, he’d make a good designated hitter, but fortunately there is no DH in the National League.

Q: Of all the spring trainings you have covered, who was the most unexpected and surprising player to earn a spot on the 25-man roster? — RON, Vandalia.

A: It wasn’t a surprise. It was a shock. In 1982, Jeff Jones, a 20th-round draft pick in 1979, hit .301 with 42 home runs and 101 RBIs. But it was with Class A Cedar Rapids. Jones had spent most of his first four years in Class A. He had a great spring training and general manager Dick Wagner insisted that manager Russ Nixon not only keep Jones, but play him in right field. The grand experiment lasted less than a month and Jones hit .221 with no homers, 13 strikeouts and 11 walks in 53 plate appearances. He was sent back to the minors, never to be heard from again. And the Reds finished last in the five-team National League West.

Q: I have always wondered why teams don’t hire batting practice pitchers who can throw curveballs and sliders that players will see in games. Wouldn’t that help players like Billy Hamilton and wouldn’t it have helped Jay Bruce? WORDMAN, Troy.

A: That’s an extremely good point. Most of the time, coaches pitch batting practice and they throw nothing but straight pitches with little velocity. I fail to see how that helps players when they face major-league pitching and see splitters, sliders and curves. I watch batting practice and before my eye problems I know I could hit those pitches. And with some of the lobs they throw I think I might still be able to put the ball in play. Yeah, yeah. I am a dreamer.

Q: When pitcher Art Fowler was released by the Reds, he said something like, “If I can’t pitch for the Reds, I must be really bad.” Does that equate with the current Reds pitching staff? — CARL, Kettering.

A: Fowler wasn’t released, he was traded to the Los Angeles Dodgers in June 1958. And knowing Fowler, that’s something he would say. What was on his mind came out of his mouth. And if any of the Reds think that, they aren’t going to say it. Most of them are just happy to have a job.

Q: Are you worried about Billy Hamilton’s slow start this spring? — UNCMIC, Cincinnati.

A: I’m not worried, but the Reds should be. Yes, it is only spring training, but they’d love to see the guy get a few hits, get on base a few times. As fast as Billy is he should never have a “slow” start in anything he does. He talks fast, he eats fast and he plays the game fast. But he looks much faster running the bases then he does walking back to the dugout.

Q: What’s your opinion of Bryan Price’s performance as manager and do you think the Reds would replace him with Barry Larkin? — LOWELL, Hamilton.

A: It would not stun me at all if Barry Larkin eventually manages the Reds. But not soon. It is hard to evaluate Price until the team puts together a stable pitching staff for him and the injury monster stays away. I love his preparation and his communication with his players. Those players just have to be a lot better before he can be fairly judged. That being said, the manager is always the fall guy.

Q: Jesse Winker is hitting and Nick Senzel hits better than Jose Peraza. Does manager Bryan Price get them in the lineup? STEVE, Miamisburg.

A: You are basing your comments on a small spring training sampling. Plus spring training statistics are highly dubious. Actually, at this writing, Peraza and Senzel both are hitting .250. And Senzel is not a shortstop and probably won’t make the 25-man roster. Winker will, indeed, get a lot of playing time and it wouldn’t surprise me if he takes over right field before the season is over.

Reader Comments

Next Up in Sports

HS Scores 12/12: Thomas leads Tecumseh in win

Boys Basketball Tuesday’s Results Alter 56, LaSalle 49: Uhl (A) 23; Lemons (L) 16 Beavercreek 60, Fairborn 57: Herbert (B) 18; Monore (F) 32 Butler 70, Northmont 60 Carlisle 66, Milton Union 44: Gay (C) 19, Stone (MU) 12. Catholic Central 55, Greeneview 34: Doolittle (S) 20; Caudill (G) 14. Cinncinnati Christian 63, St.Bernard 50: Rogers (C)...
Blackburn McCafferty trophy, which Dayton and Xavier fought over for decades, up for auction
Blackburn McCafferty trophy, which Dayton and Xavier fought over for decades, up for auction

Xavier University is auctioning off its copy of the Blackburn McCafferty Trophy, the rivalry trophy the Musketeers and the Dayton Flyers fought over for decades. The Xavier Athletics Department auction on describes the trophy as being in fair condition with “scratches to wood and metal” and “chips in the acrylic...
Trotwood-Madison’s announcement it had been voted out of the GWOC
Trotwood-Madison’s announcement it had been voted out of the GWOC

Trotwood-Madison High School was notified on Wednesday that its Greater Western Ohio Conference membership was ending. By an 8-1 vote, the Rams were informed they have until the end of the 2018-19 school year to remain in the conference. Athletic directors from the eight eventual remaining GWOC schools – Beavercreek, Centerville, Fairmont, Miamisburg...
Reds trade one Tanner for another at baseball’s winter meetings
Reds trade one Tanner for another at baseball’s winter meetings

The Cincinnati Reds traded one right-handed pitcher named Tanner for another right-handed pitcher named Tanner on Wednesday in their first deal at baseball’s winter meetings in Las Vegas, Nev. The Reds  deal Tanner Rainey to the Washington Nationals for Tanner Roark. Roark, 32, was 64-54 with a 3.59 ERA in six seasons with the Nationals...
Business as usual at Ohio State despite Urban Meyer’s pending retirement
Business as usual at Ohio State despite Urban Meyer’s pending retirement

What is the mood in the Woody Hayes Athletics Center like since Urban Meyer announced he will retire from coaching after the Rose Bowl?  Robert Landers was among the Buckeyes who described it as pretty much the same as before.  “Coach Meyer is still Coach Meyer,” the junior defensive tackle from Wayne High School said. &ldquo...
More Stories