WEATHER ALERT

Ice Storm Warning issued for entire Miami Valley

Did you see this proposed Reds-Indians trade?


In case you missed it, Jim Bowden suggested a trade between the Reds and Indians that won’t happen. 

Writing for The Athletic, the former Reds general manager proposed an in-state swap of two elite relievers for two elite prospects. 

3. Indians acquire Raisel Iglesias and Amir Garrett from the Cincinnati Reds for Francisco Mejia and Shane Bieber

The Indians have the starting pitching, offense and defense to win the World Series. However, what they’re lacking is quality bullpen depth in front of closer Cody Allen and set-up reliever Andrew Miller (when he’s healthy). The Indians need to trade for a couple relievers if they want to win the World Series. The Indians’ window to win is right now and they’ll have to pay a huge price for that opportunity. Trading top hitting prospect Mejia, who would play left field for the Reds immediately, and right-handed pitcher Bieber, who would immediately go into the Reds’ rotation, would be painful for Cleveland.

And stupid for Cincinnati. 

First and foremost, this is a reminder why Jim Bowden isn’t employed by a team as a general manager. 

However high the ceilings of these two prospects might be — and MLB.com rates Bieber as a potential No. 4 starter while noting Mejia isn’t actually an outfielder — this is not a sufficient return for two young pitchers with great arms who are having success in the majors and are not close to free agency. 

One? Maybe then we can talk, but both? Get real. 

Of course, the Indians already know this. 

Just two years ago they traded four players for stud lefty reliever Andrew Miller, who is probably the fully-developed version of Amir Garrett. 

That package included top-100 prospects Justus Sheffield and Clint Frazier. 

But it’s something to talk about I guess. 


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Sports

Gentry’s career night helps WSU knock off Toledo
Gentry’s career night helps WSU knock off Toledo

Cole Gentry scored a career-high 30 points, and Louden Love had a double-double with 14 points and 12 rebounds to lead Wright State to an 84-74 win over visiting Toledo on Wednesday. Bill Wampler chipped in 17 points and Skyelar Potter 13 as the team bounced back from a 19-point drubbing at Murray State. The Raiders (2-1) pulled away early in the second...
Signing period: Area seniors who will play at the next level
Signing period: Area seniors who will play at the next level

The week-long early signing period for basketball and the regular signing period for all NCAA Division I and II sports but football began on Wednesday, Nov. 14. NCAA D-I football will have an early signing period from Dec. 19-21. The traditional regular signing period for football is Feb. 6-April 1 of 2019. The following are area high school seniors...
Ohio State looking to extend noon dominance
Ohio State looking to extend noon dominance

Ohio State and Maryland are set to kick off at noon Saturday — the perfect time for the Buckeyes so far in the Urban Meyer era.  Perfect as in they haven’t lost a noon kickoff yet since he took over as the coach in Columbus.  The Ohio State sports information department produced that eye-opening stat this week: 29-0 in games that...
Signing day: UC lands Xenia basketball standout
Signing day: UC lands Xenia basketball standout

Samari Curtis drew more attention than he was expecting following a breakout freshman season of basketball at Xenia High School. The following season, Curtis always drew an opponent’s most dogged defender. Double-teams and go-to pressure by other defenders became the defensive norm against the high flyer. “At first, I couldn’t handle...
Hue Jackson on return to Bengals: ‘Excited to join a team in playoff contention’
Hue Jackson on return to Bengals: ‘Excited to join a team in playoff contention’

Hue Jackson was hoping he could make his way back to the Cincinnati Bengals when the Cleveland Browns fired him as their head coach three weeks ago, but he said he has no regrets about leaving Cincinnati in the first place. The Bengals named Jackson a special assistant to the head coach Tuesday to help Marvin Lewis as he assumes the role of defensive...
More Stories