Hal McCoy: How far can Reds climb? Back to .500? Wild-card contention?


Hall of Fame baseball writer Hal McCoy knows a thing or two about our nation’s pastime. Tap into that knowledge by sending an email to halmccoy1@hotmail.com.

Q: Is there a better moment in all of sports than watching a pitcher’s reaction just as the bat meets the ball on a home run blast? — DAVE, Miamisburg/Centerville/Beavercreek.

A: Some quickly hang their heads and refuse to watch the ball. Some turn quickly to catch the flight, risking neck injury. Some raise their heads to the sky and shout an expletive. Some glare at the perpetrator as he begins his home run trot and if his name was Bob Gibson he might shout, “Enjoy that, but hang loose in the batter’s box the next time you come up.”

»RELATED: 3 reasons the Reds can escape last place

Q: The Reds were 25-45 a month ago and this week they were 10 games under .500, so do you see them not only getting back to .500, but also competing for the wild card this year? — BRAYAN, Oslo, Norway.

A: As of this writing, the Reds were 41-51 and would need to go 40-30 the rest of the way to finish 81-81, a major accomplishment after a 3-18 start. They need to play .572 ball, which is tough but possible the way they’ve been playing. A wild card? That’s nearly the impossible dream. There are eight teams ahead of the Reds in the wild card standings and nearly all would have to collapse for the Reds to catch them and that isn’t going to happen. While I believe the Reds will crawl out of last place and pass the Pirates, I doubt they’ll any higher in the National League Central. But as New York Mets fans once said, “Ya gotta believe.”

»MCCOY: Would Reds consider trading top prospect?

Q: A recent article said the Reds front office was going to increase in payroll next year so do they like the makeup of the team? — JAY, Englewood.

A: Team president Dick Williams said the team will increase the $107 million payroll significantly, but he tossed in a couple of caveats. He said it depends on how the team does the rest of the season and it depends on more fans filling all those empty seats in Great American Ball Park. He also said he didn’t know yet if that meant they will sign top shelf free agents or make trades for established players. And how much is a significant boost? With how the team is playing I’m sure they like the makeup of this team. Will it continue? Stay tuned, especially around the trade deadline July 31. That will reveal the direction this team is taking.

Q: The Reds comeback win Tuesday against the Indians was incredible, so what was the best Reds comeback win you ever saw? ALAN, Sugarcreek Township.

»RELATED: MCCOY on the Reds incredible, incredulous comeback

A: That was it. As MC Hammer sang, ‘U Can’t Touch this.’ Unfortunately, the two biggest comebacks I saw involved the Reds losing. Both times they led, 9-3, entering the ninth. Both times the opposition scored seven in the ninth to win, 10-9, and both involved walk-off home runs. The first was in 2005 against St. Louis Cardinals. Closer Danny Graves gave up home runs to Jim Edmonds and John Mabry. Mabry was filling in at third base for injured Scott Rolen and he hit a two-run walk-off home run. The second was against Atlanta. Coco Cordero gave up a grand slam walk-off to Brooks Conrad. The ball hit off left fielder Laynce Nix’s glove, hit the top of the wall and went over. Conrad thought Nix caught the ball and stopped running as he rounded first base and had to be told, “Run, man, you just hit a walk-off grand slam.” Joey Votto’s three-run double felt much better.

»RELATED: 4 times the Reds have rallied to beat Indians in 9th

Q: What is the difference between pitching to contact and throwing strikes? — RON, Vandalia.

A: Mostly semantics. The only difference I can discern is that pitching to contact means to put the ball where a batter can put it in play so the defense can do its work. Don’t try to strikeout every hitter. You can throw strikes with the intent to strike out the batter with hard stuff on the fringes of the strike zone that make those pitches difficult to put in play. Either way, they avoid walks and we all know what walks do. Walks haunt.

Q: Nearly every team gets stuck with bad long-term contract, so wouldn’t it make more sense to pay players more money for one season and reward them with more money the next season if they produce? — BRIAN, Bellbrook.

»HARTMAN: Since woeful start, Reds are dramatic and fun under Riggleman

A: Try floating that one past the players’ union. Ever since players were granted free agency in 1976 a long-term contract is a player’s dream. It provides comfort and security and sometimes too much comfort. No star player would agree to a one-year contract because there are always teams dangling long-term contracts. Yes, it makes sense, but when did anything concerning salaries ever make sense in baseball?

Q: With all the news about Akron native LeBron James leaving Cleveland, was there anybody you grew up with in Akron who made it big in the pros? — EVAN, Dayton.

A: I have to get personal here. My first baseball favorite player was an outfielder named Gene Woodling. He played 17 years, mostly with the New York Yankees and Cleveland Indians. He not only was from Akron, he attended my high school, Akron East (long before I did). And then there was the guy I grew up with and played high school and college ball (Kent State) with, Gene ‘Stick’ Michael. He signed out of Kent with the Pittsburgh Pirates and played shortstop in the majors several years. He then managed the Cubs and Yankees and was general manager of the Yankees under George Steinbrenner. He always told people I had a higher batting average in high school than he did, but he made me tell them what a great basketball player he was — which he was. Thurman Munson was from Akron and the Yankees catcher and seven-time All-Star died tragically in a plane crash at the Akron-Canton airport when he was still an active player.

»RELATED: Reds all-star infield ‘a special group’

Q: I attended the recent Reds-Cubs series in Wrigley Field and is it me or have Cubs fans quit throwing opposing team’s home runs back onto the field? — RANDY, West Alexandria.

A: The tradition continues. The Bleacher Bums always throw opposing home run balls back on the field and fans who don’t do it are treated rudely. But some of them are wise. They carry old beat-up baseballs in their pockets and throw those balls on the field and keep the real one. Perhaps you saw Eugenio Suarez hit a home run over the seats and on to Waveland Avenue behind the park. But some fans outside the park have been known to throw those balls back over the stands and onto the field. I witnessed George Foster hitting one out of Wrigley in 1977 and somebody on the street threw the ball back and nearly skulled left fielder Bobby Murcer.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Sports

HS Roundup 9/19: Miami East girls golf team has record day

Two school records were set for the Miami East girls golf team in a 183-237 win versus Tri-Village on Wednesday. Paige Lawson posted a 38 to lead the way, setting a new individual low for East. Kearsten Kirby added a 44, Maci Krites a 48 and Marissa Kearns a 53. The 183 team score also marked a school record. Boys Soccer Bellefontaine 7, Indian Lake...
HS Results 9/19: Bellefontaine, Ben Logan, Northwestern win by shutout

Boys Soccer Wednesday’s Results Bellefontaine 7, Indian Lake 0 Benjamin Logan 1, Shawnee 0 Northwestern 1, Tecumseh 0 Urbana 2, Jonathan Alder 1 Tuesday’s Results Alter 0, Fenwick 0 Beavercreek 4, Northmont 0 Bellbrook 1, Eaton 1 Butler 8, Greenville 1 Centerville 2, Springboro 0 Colerain 1, Oak Hills 1 Dayton Christian 5, Bethel 1 Fairfield...
Cincinnati Bengals off to strong start, but injuries piling up
Cincinnati Bengals off to strong start, but injuries piling up

The Cincinnati Bengals are off to about as good of a start as they could hope for in terms of the results, but the same cannot be said for the health of the team. Cincinnati (2-0) travels to face the Carolina Panthers (1-1) on Sunday and will be using some backups at key positions in an offense that has been rolling through the first two games. »...
Week 4 area high school football passing leaders
Week 4 area high school football passing leaders

The following are area high school football passing leaders through Week 4. Southwest Ohio Conference: Connor Kinnett, jr., Harrison, 57 of 100 passing (57.0 percent), 1,040 yards, 10 TDs, 1 INT. Midwest Athletic Conference: Jake Hemmelgarn, jr., Coldwater, 77 of 102 passing (75.5 percent), 990 yards, 14 TDs, 4 INTs. Central Buckeye Conference: Chris...
Ryan Day to receive hefty one-time payment for serving as interim Ohio State football coach
Ryan Day to receive hefty one-time payment for serving as interim Ohio State football coach

How much is navigating a top five team through preseason and to a 3-0 start worth?  Nearly half a million dollars.  According to a letter released by the university Wednesday, Ohio State offensive coordinator and quarterbacks coach Ryan Day will be paid $487,000 for serving as interim head coach in Urban Meyer’s absence.  »...
More Stories