How do rebuilding Reds compare to division-leading Cubs?


The Cubs, as is plain to anyone, are where the Reds want to be.

After going through several seasons like Cincinnati’s club is enduring now, Chicago has roared through the first half of the season.

The Cubs entered Wednesday nine games up in the National League Central, one year after a surprising appearance in the National League Championship Series. Loaded with young talent, they seem to be preparing for a long stay at the top, too.

Their rapid ascent begs an obvious question in southwest Ohio: Into a rebuild of their own, can the Reds replicate such a turnaround?

Easy to ask, the question isn’t necessarily simple to answer, but to begin we thought we would compare the pieces each team has now. Then we’ll look to what might be around the bend for Cincinnati as far as prospects and examine what else might need to be done to get over the hump from up-and-comer to bona fide contender.

While the Reds have a couple of players in the everyday lineup who might not be in the long, long term plans, in most cases they are still accomplished MLB players.

If, by some miracle, the team turns it around quickly, players like Brandon Phillips and Joey Votto could still be productive members of a good team next season even if their best days are behind them.

Younger veterans Zack Cozart and Jay Bruce could also be parts of a good team, but the more that looks like it could be true, the less likely they are to be on the team next season.

Meanwhile, 27-year-old Adam Duvall just made his first All-Star team and there is hope the best days are still ahead for Billy Hamilton, Eugenio Suarez and Tucker Barnhart, all of whom are 25 or younger.

That leads us to a somewhat surprising revelation: The everyday lineups are not that much different on paper.

With an average age of 27.3 years, the Cubs are only a year younger than the Reds. Both teams start three players 30 or over, and both teams have three players 25 or younger.

While the Reds have four players who have been named to an All-Star team – including Duvall – the Cubs have five headed to the 2016 Midsummer Classic.

The Cubs would appear to have more elite talent, though. While the Reds have only one everyday player in 2016 who was a first-round draft pick (Bruce), Chicago has three in Kris Bryant, Addison Russell and Jason Heyward.

As far as pitching staffs, the picture is a bit different. The Reds’ rebuild has affected this area much more significantly than the lineup so far, as is made obvious by the fact none of Cincinnati’s starters are over 27. Chicago, meanwhile, has only one starter (Kyle Hendricks) under 30.

The Reds can also boast of better pedigree in the rotation, although that hasn’t counted for much so far this season when it comes to results (especially when facing the young, talented Cubs lineup).

The Reds start a first-rounder in Brandon Finnegan and a second-rounder in Cody Reed. John Lamb and Anthony DeSclafani went in the fifth and sixth rounds, respectively, while Dan Straily was a 24th-rounder. When healthy, Homer Bailey will give the Reds another first-rounder, and first-rounder Robert Stephenson might not be far away.

No Cubs starters were taken in the first round, but veterans John Lackey and Jon Lester both went in the second round. Their other three starters all went from the fifth through the 10th.

Now, how did these teams get this way?

The Reds built their division winners of 2010 and ’12 largely through the draft, and the remnants of that effort remain on the last-place 2016 squad. Five of Cincinnati’s everyday eight are homegrown while the Cubs boast only a pair of players they signed or drafted themselves.

(Until Bailey returns or Stephenson is called up, neither team has a starter who started his pro career with the organization.)

So what does that tell us? That what used to be one of the best teams in the division was built differently than the one currently on top.

What does that mean for the future?

We’ll take a look at how the Reds of tomorrow might compare (and how they were acquired) Thursday.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Sports

High School Football: Week 5 boxscores, scores
High School Football: Week 5 boxscores, scores

Allen East 50, Delphos Jefferson 6 Alter 45, Fenwick 20 Anderson 47, Withrow 12 Badin 42, Roger Bacon 35, OT Bellbrook 21, Franklin 17 Bellefontaine 14, Ben Logan 6 Brookville 42, Carlisle 2 Butler 13, Xenia 7, OT Celina 42, Ottawa-Glandorf 24 Chaminade Julienne 61, Carroll 30 Cin. Country Day 28, New Miami 20 Clinton-Massie 34, Bishop Hartley 31 Col...
Henry scores school-record 6 touchdowns to lead CJ past Carroll
Henry scores school-record 6 touchdowns to lead CJ past Carroll

Chaminade Julienne celebrated its homecoming victory Friday night at Roger Glass Stadium as a community. The students surrounded the team on the field right after the game as they always do. They helped sing the alma mater. They listened to head coach Marcus Colvin’s speech. They joined a chant and jumped up and down with the players. In the...
McCoy: Who are top starting pitchers Reds could pursue in free agency?
McCoy: Who are top starting pitchers Reds could pursue in free agency?

Q: I saw a list of the all-time Top 25 players with sweet swings, headed by Ken Griffey Jr., and does it surprise you that Joey Votto is not on the list? — DAVE, Miamisburg/Centerville/Beavercreek. A: Have you seen some of those defensive thrusts Votto takes to foul off pitches? Efficient, but not sweet. Votto’s swings are not picturesque...
Butler senior wins Junior Tournament Bowlers Association event
Butler senior wins Junior Tournament Bowlers Association event

Second place was a familiar finish for the Sacks brothers until Sunday. “Between me and my brother Eric, I think we had close to 10 second-place JTBA finishes,” Drew Sacks said. “I guess I finally broke the curse.” Drew won the Junior Tournament Bowlers Association Ohio Valley Bank Open in Gallipolis Sunday. The Butler High...
Kettering’s Day wins City Stroke Play Championship
Kettering’s Day wins City Stroke Play Championship

Fifty-one golfers teed it up twice in the City Stroke Play Championship last weekend at Kittyhawk Golf Center, but only one – Paul Day – managed to break par for 18 holes. Day, a 34-year-old Kettering software support specialist, fired a 3-under-par 69 Saturday on the Hawk course and turned in a 3-over-par 75 on the Eagle course Sunday...
More Stories