Hartman: Maybe the Reds needed a couple of veteran starting pitchers after all?


Jeff Brantley made an interesting point during the Reds broadcast Tuesday night about the impact of signing David Hernandez and Jarred Hughes to stabilize the bullpen. 

Would bringing in two veterans have the same effect on the starting rotation? 

The former Reds closer thinks so, and obviously his opinion carries some weight given his experience and knowledge of the craft — not to mention clubhouse dynamics. 

RELATED: ‘Big Sal’ strong as Reds top TigersVotto does bird a favor with grand slam

I was not an advocate of signing anyone in the winter because I wanted to see what the young guys can do, but maybe I was wrong. 

(Several of them did finish strong last season.)

I’m a fan of upside and believe raw talent usually wins out in the end, but at some point you have to be able to get outs no matter how talented you are. 

Brantley went on to say young players learn better from veteran players than from coaches because they are peers and spend more time together. He also threw some shade at Homer Bailey, saying the team needs veterans who actually communicate with the young guys to help them along. 

Of course it’s easier to say they needed those veterans now since the first two months were such a disaster. 

Pretty much anything would have been better, right? 

» RELATED: Suarez playing like an all-star

Even if the starting pitching had been decent from the start, they would be below .500 at this point thanks to the slow start for so many at the plate (since reversed) and the ongoing putrid defense and base running. 

Also there is the possibility that even if veterans stabilized the rotation and helped the club get back to .500, that’s all the farther they would be able to get without more premium arms in place. 

There’s no one way to build a contender, but it’s interesting stuff to think about. 

  

That discussion between Brantley and Thom Brennaman came from a conversation about the potential trade value of Hernandez and Hughes. 

The more I think about it, I would keep those guys unless I was offered something really phenomenal - like another Luis Castillo-type talent, not just a potential regular but someone with real star potential. 

Maybe that comes along. I tend to doubt it. 

At some point, the rebuild has to stop. 

Even the World Series champions need to open always to ways to improve the club, but you also can’t be constantly tearing down over here while building over there. 

Ask the Pirates how that worked out in the post-Barry Bonds years. 

>>RELATED: Former Cincinnati GM proposes terrible Reds-Indians trade

It’s become clear not all fans get the necessity of tearing down to rebuild, especially for a small-market team, and some painful decisions are always going to have to be made. 

However, at some point more of an investment has to be made at the major-league level to give fans something to believe in — and in this case to avoid again having a terrible bullpen if/when the starters finally come around. 

The best PR strategy is always to win. 

The best way to get good for a long time is to be bad for a little while, but every fan base has its limits. 

Reds fans seem to be understandably near, if not beyond, theirs, so it’s time to make some moves based on the present. 


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Sports

Here’s how Ohio State fans reacted to coach Urban Meyer’s return to the Buckeyes
Here’s how Ohio State fans reacted to coach Urban Meyer’s return to the Buckeyes

Fans of the Ohio State Buckeyes welcomed coach Urban Meyer back with open arms Saturday as he returned to the sideline following a three-game suspension. At the first glimpse of Meyer before he walked to the Skull Session with the team, fans started cheering. Before he could speak to the crowd at St. John Arena, fans drowned him out with applause....
Haskins, Campbell star as Buckeyes cruise to halftime lead over Tulane
Haskins, Campbell star as Buckeyes cruise to halftime lead over Tulane

Back home for a final tuneup before the Big Ten schedule resumes, Ohio State made building a 42-6 first-half lead over Tulane look easy. The fourth-ranked Buckeyes scored touchdowns on all six possessions, including five TD tosses by Dwayne Haskins. The sophomore starter completed 21 of 24 passes for 304 yards. Parris Campbell caught eight passes for...
Springfield, Miamisburg last two unbeaten GWOC football teams
Springfield, Miamisburg last two unbeaten GWOC football teams

Springfield and Miamisburg are the only two remaining unbeaten high school football teams in the 20-member Greater Western Ohio Conference. Both are 5-0 after Week 5 wins on Friday. The teams are not scheduled to play in the regular season, but could be paired in the playoffs. Springfield improved to No. 2 in the Division I, Region 3 computer rankings...
Eldora Speedway provided the scene for a famous victory that stunned the racing world in 1998
Eldora Speedway provided the scene for a famous victory that stunned the racing world in 1998

Twenty years ago at Eldora Speedway, all eyes were on Jack Hewitt. Even those of the other drivers’ wives. Hewitt had won the first three features at the 4-Crown Nationals with wins in the USAC Midgets, USAC sprints and UMP Modifieds. All that remained for dirt track history – becoming the first driver to sweep all four divisions &ndash...
Archdeacon: One of Ohio’s best-ever high school sports stories is now a book by a Miami graduate. Here’s why he told it.
Archdeacon: One of Ohio’s best-ever high school sports stories is now a book by a Miami graduate. Here’s why he told it.

He remembers how excited the five of them were to come to Dayton. Wil Haygood was just 17. One of his pals was able to borrow a car, all of them pooled their money for gas and they headed from Columbus to UD Arena to see their hero. It was Feb. 26, 1972 and Southwestern Louisiana, the No. 10 team in the nation, was playing the Dayton Flyers. The Ragin&rsquo...
More Stories