March Madness: Let’s pick NCAA tournament winners by mascot

As mentioned in today’s column, I came up with a pretty chalky result in my first take on this year’s NCAA tournament. 

I am going to look into a few enticing matchups and might revise my picks before submitting final answers, but here’s one that couldn’t wait. 

My annual mascot bracket! 

I figured we might as well have some fun before seeing my real picks start to go down in flames — plus it might be interesting (and/or sad) to see if these picks beat my real ones. 

So, here we go, starting with the South region: 

Virginia in real life is a tough out because Tony Bennett’s team plays great defense. 

In the mascot bracket, the Cavaliers benefit from having a horse and sword to wield against dogs and cats in the early rounds. 

Alas, those are no match for a natural disaster, right? 

Miami marches out of the South region after literally blowing away the competition. 

Also of note: I picked Tennessee over Wright State because the Volunteers have guns, which beat both wolves and viking raiders. 

This region also has my biggest upset of the entire bracket: Georgia State over Cincinnati. 

Sorry, UC fans, but is there any other predator a real bearcat could beat? Certainly not a panther. 

The East presents a similar challenge for the No. 1 seed Villanova. 

Could a wildcat really beat a Crimson Tide? Or an elephant for that matter? 

Hard to imagine that, so Alabama moves on to the Sweet 16. 

Marshall’s Thundering Herd is also taking down the Shockers in the first round, but the guns of the West Virginia Mountaineers subdue their rivals in the round of 32. 

I gave the nod to Arkansas over Purdue in the second round on the understanding pigs rule, but the Razorbacks are still going to have a hard time competing with guns. That means Texas Tech is in the Elite Eight, where Alabama washes the Red Raiders away to earn a trip to San Antonio. 

In the Midwest, Kansas gets a pass in found one because the Quakers refuse to fight, but Seton Hall presents big trouble in round two. 

How is a mythical bird going to beat a Pirate? 

Seton Hall should take that one and will find guns a decisive advantage against Tigers — be they from Clemson or Auburn — in the Sweet 16. 

Oklahoma-Rhode Island is a tough call because Rams are mean and resourceful, but again I’m going to assume the Sooners have guns and are willing to cheat to win. 

I initially had Duke coming out of this bracket, but upon learning the Blue Devils are named after a French military unit I immediately assumed they would be at a disadvantage against, well, pretty much everyone. 

That opens the door for Michigan State’s Spartans, who benefit from superior training and a willingness to die for the cause that is enough to overcome more sophisticated weaponry. 

That just leaves the West, where again we see the No. 1 seed with a tricky matchup in round two. 

Xavier vs. Florida State: Could a fancy-pantsed French guy with a sword handle a band of proud Native American fighters? In Nashville, no less? 

Not by himself, but this is where the Blue Blob sweeps in to dominate the battlefield and move XU into the Sweet 16. 

That’s as far as Xavier can go, though, because both of its mascots would literally be paralyzed by ingesting Buckeyes in the Sweet 16. 

(This is a big break for Ohio State, by the way, as Native Americans actually ate buckeyes according to the USDA.) 

Ohio State fans will enjoy the bottom of this bracket, too, as there is pretty much no doubt a Michigan Wolverine is not going to have a chance against a Grizzly bear from Montana. 

The poison trump card sends the Buckeyes to the Final Four, where they join a group of humans and two forces of nature.  

The national championship game comes down to a tiebreaker. 

I couldn’t figure out who would win between a massive wave and a hurricane, but after a stalemate ensued the secondary mascots provide an obvious choice. 

Alabama takes home the championship after the elephant stomps the ibis into oblivion. 


Reader Comments

Next Up in Sports

HS Scores 12/12: Thomas leads Tecumseh in win

Boys Basketball Tuesday’s Results Alter 56, LaSalle 49: Uhl (A) 23; Lemons (L) 16 Beavercreek 60, Fairborn 57: Herbert (B) 18; Monore (F) 32 Butler 70, Northmont 60 Carlisle 66, Milton Union 44: Gay (C) 19, Stone (MU) 12. Catholic Central 55, Greeneview 34: Doolittle (S) 20; Caudill (G) 14. Cinncinnati Christian 63, St.Bernard 50: Rogers (C)...
Blackburn McCafferty trophy, which Dayton and Xavier fought over for decades, up for auction
Blackburn McCafferty trophy, which Dayton and Xavier fought over for decades, up for auction

Xavier University is auctioning off its copy of the Blackburn McCafferty Trophy, the rivalry trophy the Musketeers and the Dayton Flyers fought over for decades. The Xavier Athletics Department auction on describes the trophy as being in fair condition with “scratches to wood and metal” and “chips in the acrylic...
Trotwood-Madison’s announcement it had been voted out of the GWOC
Trotwood-Madison’s announcement it had been voted out of the GWOC

Trotwood-Madison High School was notified on Wednesday that its Greater Western Ohio Conference membership was ending. By an 8-1 vote, the Rams were informed they have until the end of the 2018-19 school year to remain in the conference. Athletic directors from the eight eventual remaining GWOC schools – Beavercreek, Centerville, Fairmont, Miamisburg...
Reds trade one Tanner for another at baseball’s winter meetings
Reds trade one Tanner for another at baseball’s winter meetings

The Cincinnati Reds traded one right-handed pitcher named Tanner for another right-handed pitcher named Tanner on Wednesday in their first deal at baseball’s winter meetings in Las Vegas, Nev. The Reds  deal Tanner Rainey to the Washington Nationals for Tanner Roark. Roark, 32, was 64-54 with a 3.59 ERA in six seasons with the Nationals...
Business as usual at Ohio State despite Urban Meyer’s pending retirement
Business as usual at Ohio State despite Urban Meyer’s pending retirement

What is the mood in the Woody Hayes Athletics Center like since Urban Meyer announced he will retire from coaching after the Rose Bowl?  Robert Landers was among the Buckeyes who described it as pretty much the same as before.  “Coach Meyer is still Coach Meyer,” the junior defensive tackle from Wayne High School said. &ldquo...
More Stories