Sorry, ACC, this is the NCAA tournament change we’d rather see


The ACC is proposing a change to the NCAA tournament that is dumb and unnecessary. 

Per reports, members of the once-proud basketball conference that sold its soul for football several years back would like to see four more teams make the Big Dance each spring, bringing the total number to 72. 

ACC commissioner John Swofford says this would create a second First Four, though it would not. That would actually require going to a field of 76. 

» LOOKING BACK: Dayton overwhelmed with joy to keep First Four

That little oversight should probably tell us a lot about how much thought went into this proposal, but while we’re having this conversation, here’s the change that really should be made. 

The last thing the NCAA tournament needs is more teams considering we already give at-large bids to schools that can’t even finish above .500 in their league. 

Instead of expanding the field, the NCAA basketball committee should right a wrong that has existed since the play-in game was created and awarded to Dayton at the dawn of the century. 

No automatic bid winner should have to play before the round of 64 starts on Thursday and Friday of the first weekend of the tournament. 

You win and you’re in, not halfway. 

The folks who put on the First Four do an awesome job of making the experience as much as possible like it would be at the weekend sites, but it is still not the same thing. 

There is still an extra game, extra travel, less time to prepare, etc. 

RELATED: First Four staying in Dayton until at least 2022

The First Four should consist of the last eight at-large teams, a change that is more fair to the 16 seeds now and only punishes teams that barely deserve to be in the field anyway.

(A win-win!) 

Plus this likely would increase interest (and TV ratings) in the Tuesday and Wednesday games since the teams that would end up in this revamped First Four would likely have larger fanbases and higher-profile brands than the 16 seeds who make up half of it now. 

What’s not to like? 

Make it happen, committee! 


Reader Comments


Next Up in Sports

HS Roundup 1/15: Fairmont takes buzzer-beater win over Fairborn

Ryan Hall dropped in a basket at the buzzer to lead Fairmont boys basketball in a 56-54 win versus visiting Fairmont on Tuesday night. Hall poured in 19 points for Fairmont and Andre O’Daniel added 13 points. Shaunn Monroe of Fairborn led all scorers with 25 points. Fairmont improved to 10-4 and 4-3 in conference play; Fairborn fell to 8-4 and...
HS Scores 1/15: Centerville boys beat St. X, Lebanon falls in OT

Boys Basketball Tuesday’s Results Anderson 53, Harrison 31 Ansonia 57, Union City (IN) 45: Good (UC) 17; Muir (A) 15. Badin 71, Talawanda 50: Switzer (B) 13; James (T) 15. Beavercreek 52, Wilmington 45: Saleh (B) 16; Coomer (W) 16. Bellefontaine 71, Indian Lake 61, OT Belmont 73, Troy 50: K. Moore (B) 24; Monroe (T) 20. Ben Logan 58, West Liberty-Salem...
Girls high school basketball state polls
Girls high school basketball state polls

How a state panel of sports writers and broadcasters rates Ohio high school girls basketball teams in the Associated Press polls, by OHSAA divisions, with won-lost record and total points (first-place votes in parentheses): DIVISION I 1, Pickerington Central (13) 11-1 210 2, Cin. Princeton (2) 12-0 180 3, Canton McKinley (4) 11-1 167 4, Cin. Mt. Notre...
Mulching a 200-yard stretch of hiking trail no match for Beavercreek wrestling team
Mulching a 200-yard stretch of hiking trail no match for Beavercreek wrestling team

Six minutes on the mat can leave even the most experienced wrestlers taxed mentally and physically exhausted. So can, as the Beavercreek Beavers found out, mulching a 200-yard stretch of hiking trail at Caesar Creek State Park. Beavercreek coach Gary Wise takes pride in his team’s history of community service. So when officials at Caesar Creek...
Green confident Dayton can bounce back after one-point loss at GW
Green confident Dayton can bounce back after one-point loss at GW

Coach Shauna Green has no complaints about her team’s defense since the start of Atlantic 10 Conference play. The Dayton Flyers have held their first three opponents to 45, 47 and 46 points. Except for one quarter, Dayton’s offense has played well, too. However, that one quarter — a five-point fourth quarter Saturday in Washington...
More Stories